Yet another film of Philippe Garrels with his mutli-rumple haired son Louis as Francois in the lead role. He’s fallen in love with Carole (Laura Smet) falling in love with him.
Well, she is a bit of dish. She only had to capture him with this smile while he was photoing her – and he was automatically snapped into her seductive clutches.
She’s a married celebrity actress whose film director husband is away long term in Hollywood. Feeling neglected, she’s ripe for some romantic lovering.
Its difficult to gauge how serious this love affair is given how adolescent she is about it.
We don’t have much to go on. They keep saying they love one another but we don’t see much evidence to substantiate what will eventually turn out to be – their fatal attraction.
Carole gets into playing the Love Law of Windshield Wipers. She consciously flirts with another man at a party to deliberately test Francoise; see how much she can wound him into jealous possession. She wants to make him hurt, see him suffering.
(The Law of Windshield Wipers indicates that the more one lover wants, the more the other lover has to withhold and pull away; with the proviso that this push-pull dynamic is then reversed)
Eventually, Carole realises she’s gone far enough in tormenting the poor lad, and feels the suffering of what she loves rebounded back within herself.
Carole, it turns out, is more of a hurtee than a hurter; bi-polared up to her be-brittled brink. Insecure as fuck. Desperate as hell. Well, she has to be, because she ends up in a mental asylum strapped into a straight-jacket having electro-convulsive therapy. And all because Francois has left her for another woman.
None of this is really making much sense. It all feels far too fraught and melodramatic. It isn’t at all clear, or properly motivated, why she’s going into mega breakdown mode. What is it about Francois that she’s finding too unbearable to be without?
And why has she now gone and killed herself? Anyway, I don’t care. It all smacks of self-induced, self-indulgent, neurosis if you ask me.
But she hasn’t finished with Francois quite yet. Even though she’s dead. She’s going to haunt him through his subconscious yearnings. She’s going to torment him again. Appear in mirrors, to taunt him to come back to her (in her afterlife)
And he seems powerless to resist. Even though he’s about to get married and be set up in conventional life as a husband and a dad. Carole’s demonic love is about to possess him – and take him away.
He’s just jumped out the window.
They will be re-united at last (and forever more)
This hasn’t worked at all. There is next to no character development. There is nothing about their relationship that is either credible or convincing. All the silly supernaturnal baloney in the third part beggars belief.
What a sloppy, superficial, film this has been.
Dir: Philippe Garrel, France
4/10